About Me

My photo
I blog. I also mother, wife, create, preserve, recycle, cook, act, quilt, exercise, laugh, write, lolligag, work, volunteer, sing, and sometimes sleep.

Saturday, September 19, 2015

One Year



Noah Rhoads
Photo by Jim Collum

Here was a boy who was born on a beautiful day in March to a mom and dad who were no strangers to the shortness of life, but who welcomed their son into the world with hope, love, and unimaginable joy.

Here was a boy who played with his brother, who lived in a redwood forest, who had a loving extended family so big no family tree could hold or explain them.

Here is a boy who understood empathy from the time he was walking. Sensitive, brilliant, funny, adept at the things he would try to do, exceptional at the things he put his mind and heart to.

Here was a boy who fought his demons… Sometimes winning, sometimes losing. He fought against injustice, whether it be family feuds on Facebook or with people he never met.  His brain was so strong and his mind often so made up, it was hard to argue with him, even for those of us good at arguing.


Here is a boy who, on September 19, 2014, decided the world would be better without him in it. He decided everyone's life would be easier if he were gone. Boy was he wrong.

I have shed tears of regret. Regret for words I can never say, apologies I can never make, actions I can never undo, conversations I will never finish.

 I have shed tears of pain. The pain of watching my sister, my children, and our family go through the horror of losing this young man in his prime in this way that seems avoidable. And yet, even if he had been unsuccessful a year ago, there is no guarantee he wouldn't have kept trying until he was. He was stubborn like that.

I have shed tears of sadness. Sadness for holidays which will always seem a little more empty, birthdays that will pass without being able to celebrate, the joy that is forever gone. The family that is forever changed.

Noah, I wish you were here. I wish you were here to snuggle with Tuna, to drive your mom crazy, and unflappably share your opinions… even when they weren't popular.  I wish you were here to play video games with your brother, have Sunday morning breakfast with the family, and swim with your cousins.  I wish I could hug you again and listen to you tell me all about what is going on. But none of those wishes will be. And not one of us is better for it.

I will keep thinking about you, and I will still cry, and sometimes I will be angry.  I will keep swimming, keep putting one foot in front of the other, and keep trying to help your mom make sense of all this, even though there is no sense to be made.

Here was a boy who thought he was doing the right thing.  And who was wrong.  

5 comments:

Wanda said...

I am sorry to hear that. I can listen to your deepest heart tearing a lot.

Zeph Rhoads said...

He wasn't wrong. He did the only thing he could do. It's tragic, but when his mind drove him to such despair, living was a painful curse. Enough years of torture and eventually he broke. My brother was a victim of himself. I respect his decision whether or not it hurts me. His life was his alone, and I wouldn't wish his pain on my worst enemy. I love you Ariella, and everything else you said here was on point. But I can't be silent when my whole family and the world thinks he was wrong. He was dying from the inside out, slowly and painfully. He wasn't wrong. I don't care how many people he hurt. I would never put my own selfish desires before his pain, because his pain was far more intense than the pain of anyone else, including me. We survive daily. He couldn't. That doesn't make him wrong any more than it makes him selfish or weak.
Sorry if this comes off strong. It's a deep wound, and I struggle with feeling that he is misunderstood even after death. The only thing my brother was wrong about was saying we would be better off without him. But I respect his decision and will do so for the rest of my life. I may not be better off, but he was. His torment was great enough that he felt death was preferable, whether we like it or not. Not everyone who commits suicide made a mistake. He knew what he was doing. He thought it through. And I choose to honor my brother's choice, despite the overwhelming popular belief that suicide is never justified.

Sorry if this is an overreaction to a post from a year ago... But today is hard for me. And its important to me that Noah be remembered for who he was, and that his decision is not condemned but accepted and understood as much as possible.
Thank you for caring so much and writing something beautiful. I'm just really worked up today I guess.

Unknown said...

Thank you Zeph for writing all of that. It helps. I love you.

Ariella said...

Zeph,

I totally understand and respect what you are saying, and I want you to know that when I say he was wrong...what I meant was that he was wrong that the world would be better off without him, that your mom would have it easier, and all the things the demons told him. BELIEVE me when I tell you I understand his pain and why it made sense to him to do what he did. I would never ever ever think of him as selfish OR weak. You know that there have been times in my life where I've been in that place and so I absolutely understand why someone would make the decision he did. I also think that nothing any of us did would likely have changed anything. Which is hard as hell for those of us who are "fixers" to believe. But it's true.

But I hear you and you're allowed to get as worked up as you want about all of it. It's your right and as hard as it is to FEEL, it's part of being human. You're allowed to disagree and rail against opinions you disagree with, even when it's unpopular. You're allowed to honor your brother's choice. I'd never want to deny you of those things. I'm not perfect. My opinions aren't perfect. That's just life, you know?

Love you so much...
Auntie Ariella

Unknown said...

I'm feeling overwhelmed and sad and uplifted and blessed by both of you and your words. I love your willingness to say unpopular things Zeph. And I completely get it. Hugs all around.